Soapbox: why I stopped loving Liverpool


Pete Sixsmith, one the of the best things happen to football writing in a generation (or six), reaches – I won’t say celebrates – a milestone birthday today. No prizes are being offered for guessing which one. He marks the occasion with some heartfelt words on how the magneticism of Liverpool, for him, rubbed off …

Growing up in the 60s, there was only one place boys wanted to be and that was on the banks of the Mersey.

As a regular reader of NME, Record Mirror, Melody Maker and Disc & Music Echo, I knew all about the Mersey Sound – The Beatles, The Undertakers, The Big 3, Rory Storm and The Hurricanes et al and I desperately wanted to be at the Cavern, rubbing shoulders with Gerry Marsden and thighs with Cilla Black.

Football wise, Merseyside was the centre of the universe in the first half of the decade, with Everton as the aristocrats. Goodison Park really was a cathedral of football in those days and Anfield was the slightly down at heel home of the city’s second team.

But Liverpool had something that the Blues didn’t have and that was street cred. Much of it came from their manager, the wonderful Bill Shankly, who seemed to tap into the city’s psyche far better than the aloof, Darlington-born Harry Catterick. Shankly was one of those who comes along once in a generation – Clough, Mourinho, Ferguson are his equivalents, strong men with opinions that upset some and inspired many.

When Shankly came to Liverpool they were on their uppers, stuck in Division Two while Everton lorded it over them in Division One. He changed the culture of the club, created the Fortress Anfield myth and signed players like Ron Yeats, Ian St John and Willie Stevenson to complement local lads like Roger Hunt and Ronnie Moran.

The club took off like Yuri Gagarin’s Vostok 1 and they departed Division Two, leaving us behind for a couple of years.

By the time we joined them in the top flight in 1964, they were well on their way to becoming the leading club in the country. The Kop, with its irreverent songs and chants heralded a new type of football watching, where fans interacted with the players rather than clapping, waving rattles or throwing hats in the air.

I first saw them on Boxing Day 1964 when they beat us 3-2 at Roker in a tremendous game, notable for the first appearance of Sixsmith in a red and white scarf, courtesy of Santa Claus and The Star Knitting Company of Huddersfield.

Throughout the 60s and 70s they collected trophies and fans; my younger brother was a Liverpool fan before he started going to Sunderland and they earned the undying affection of Mackems when they slaughtered the Mags in the second most enjoyable cup final I have witnessed.

Shankly retired and was replaced by Bob Paisley and they got better and better. Dalglish, Souness, Kennedy, Grobelaar, all marvelous players and all kept in place by the most avuncular manager in the game. I can’t imagine Bob Paisley ever behaving like Wenger or Ferguson and constantly knocking referees or refusing to accept that the better team won – not many did in his day!!

It all went wrong with the appointment of Graeme Souness after the Fagan, Dalglish, Moran period. Fine player that he was, he was a pragmatist rather than a romantic and he began what I see as Liverpool’s decline as a club. Poor signings, poor tactics and an arrogance that had served him well as a player let him down as a manager.

It’s about this time that I began to fall out with Liverpool as, for me, they ceased to be a city club and began to attract “fans” from all arts and parts whose only real connection with Anfield was through television, newspapers and a desire to talk about a big club in the pub, rather than their home town clubs like Darlington, Bristol Rovers and Mansfield.

After Souness we had to suffer Houllier, a manager who was never beaten fairly, always looking for an excuse for defeat and training his players in the art of the triple jump a la Gary McAllister at the Stadium of Light in 2002. Who can ever forget (or indeed be allowed to forget), that stupendous leap into the penalty area from the edge of the centre circle and the ridiculous Graham Barber awarding a penalty?

After Houllier we had Benitez, the luckiest manager in the entire history of the whole wide world. Success against AC Milan was more due them losing their bottle rather than anything Benitez did and boy, did he live on that success. I just didn’t like him and thought that some of his behavior was bizarre – his Ferguson list, his attitude towards the admittedly idiotic owners and his absurd signings.

For me, Liverpool are like William Hague in that they lost their mojo between the two Dalglish periods. They may well be in the process of re-discovering it; Dalglish knows the club, the city and is a link with the immediate post Shankly era. He did good business in shipping out Torres and has a good one in Luis Suarez. I’ll reserve judgement on the show pony he took off The Mags’ hands.

It should be a good game on Sunday. The ground will be full, we may have two fit forwards and there is bound to be controversy (McAllister’s dive, the beach ball incident, the free kick cock up at Anfield) so Sky should enjoy it.

I can’t see Liverpool ever being restored to my favourites list. The older I get, the more I dislike the alleged top four clubs who dominate the media at the expense of the likes of Sunderland Bolton and Stoke (ok, not them). But that’s just the bitterness of an old man who has to wait another 12 bloody months for his bus pass thanks to this robbing Tory government …

Tags: , , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

11 Responses to “Soapbox: why I stopped loving Liverpool” Subscribe

  1. salutsunderland March 18, 2011 at 1:46 pm #

    Whoever you support, you are welcome within reason to post comments. But if you are doing so for the first time, please bear with us if your sparkling prose is delayed briefly for moderation (chiefly for the purpose of blocking spam).

  2. Chambers March 18, 2011 at 2:06 pm #

    How sad to be so bitter…..

  3. Jacques March 18, 2011 at 3:08 pm #

    Good article Pete. I’m a Red and a Scouser too, an increasingly endangered species!

    That is a joke really; we actually have as many supporters in the city as we always did but the global appeal of the club sometimes sees us squeezed out.

    Working class heroes who would have been legends on the Kop back in the day now have to make do with watching in the pub. It isn’t the most affluent of cities, Liverpool, (moreso with Anfield itself) and as I struggle to rationally justify the costly expenditure involved with keeping my season ticket, I’m acutely aware of football’s increasing move to being as much a middle class pursuit as it is for the working man.

    International support has boosted revenues etc. and it is great to think of your club as being beloved the world over but it is depressing when you find Norwegian fans or Wools getting in ahead of Scousers. Some foreign fans, or fans from elsewhere in England are great- I don’t want to knock them all. A lot of them though just want to come to the game, listen to ‘You’ll Never Walk Alone’ and then sit down for 2 hours. Hopefully a new stadium, or a refurbished Anfield, will let us get more Scousers in.

    As for the big teams domination of the media, I think you’re right to feel bitter as your team, and others of similar worth, are marginalised. The English media is a joke. They pander and just perpetuate the pre-established narrative of their choosing.

    Hopefully will be a good game (ie a win for us!). We’ve struggled with injuries of late and are still missing Kelly and Gerrard but hopefully Carroll will be fit enough to start with Suarez for the first time, though I hope Skrtel and Carra can restrain themselves from constant hoofing like last night.

    Finally, you’ll get no argument from me about the Tories…

  4. Jeremy March 18, 2011 at 3:20 pm #

    Happy Birthday Pete. All the best mate!

  5. salutsunderland March 18, 2011 at 3:37 pm #

    Jacques. Great, thoughtful response for which many thanks. I think Chambers completely missed the point that this was a genuine expression of sadness at the way things have changed. I say that as the father of a Liverpool supporter (I have already admitted that I failed abysmally in my parental role).

  6. Jeremy March 18, 2011 at 3:44 pm #

    I can only echo the thoughts of Salut regarding Jacques post. I couldn’t disagree with a single word. Excellent stuff. It’s always great to get visits from fans of other clubs, especially when they produce that kind of input.

  7. albie March 18, 2011 at 4:13 pm #

    Enjoyed that pete.

    Fine writing.

    Two of my earliest clear football memories are our early season anihalations – 3-0 and 4 -1 – of your lot in August 1961. I was at the Anfield game. St John and Rowdy had not long signed. I can recollect the excitement in the air as if it was yesterday. The first game was at Anfield on the saturday. The follow up at Roker park was the following Tuesday night. When the 4-1 result came through I can remember dancing round the back kitchen with my dear old long gone dad. neither of us could believe we’d tonked the ‘Millionaaires’ and favourites for promotion twice in a few days.

    Amazing. Thank’s for stirring the memory banks. My first ever away with mates was Roker Park in ’66. Nil Nil draw I seem to recall. A month of fifteen and had 6 pintts of mild in I think the Black cats club?

    Happy days. As you say – life has turned in on itself since those pre-telly days of the simple life. Now where did I put that flat cap? :-0)

  8. Martin March 18, 2011 at 5:52 pm #

    Flippin fantastic article. Instead of the bus, walking is a better option for you Pete. This way your heart will be healthier, your chances of greater longevity will improve, and we get to read more of your talented spiel. And to boot, without a labour government, the country won’t be in mega-trillions of debt!! Chambers comment isn’t worth commenting on, but Jacques “they panderand just perpetuate the pre-established narrative of their choosing”. Best sentence from a visiting supporter I have read so far! Who’s Kelly though? The only Kelly I know of is Kenny’s daughter!

  9. Jacques March 18, 2011 at 7:07 pm #

    @Martin
    Kelly! You don’t know Kelly!? The Premier League’s latest superstar!?!?!?!

    Only kidding, he’s just an academy graduate. To be fair though, he has been one of our standout performers this season. Had this not been such a crummy season for us, he’d be in the England squad by now. He’s a centre back by trade who has been playing right-back for us (moving England’s first choice right-back Johnson to left-back).

    @salutsunderland
    Your lad is a Red, eh? Could be worse, he could support United or even Chelsea…

    • salutsunderland March 18, 2011 at 9:21 pm #

      Even worse. It’s not a lad but a lass. I naturally accuse her of glory-seeking (some time ago).

  10. Alan March 18, 2011 at 10:41 pm #

    Hard to believe youve reached that milestone. (mind I’m not far behind you when I think about it). Seems like yesterday that you were reporting on the efforts of Bishop Grammar first team in their epic battles agianst the likes of Washington, Hookergate and Guisborough and pinning the reports to the school notice board!
    Anyway Happy birthday Sixer. Good article as ever. Catch you at the match.

Leave a Reply

Promotion poll: Sunderland vie with Portsmouth but can Burton, Lincoln or Doncaster make top six?

Plenty of this from the Roker End last night.

John McCormick, associate editor, writes: things have quietened down with our ‘who to follow’ poll, as we might expect. Portsmouth, […]

Page generated in 3.021 seconds. Stats plugin by www.blog.ca