Jake demands answers

Jake demands answers

Peter Reid is 57, Niall Quinn 47. Perhaps too late to return to Man City as midfield dynamo and target man. But both would receive huge warm welcomes if they could find time to get along to one of the functions run by the City Disabled Supporters’ Association. The invitation is extended via Salut! Sunderland by the association’s secretary, our ‘Who are You?’ interviewee, Mark Barber*. How about three unlikely points for ‘predictably unpredictable’ SAFC, as Jake called us the other day, in return for an evening with Reidy and Niall? I bet they’re rooting for us, not City, in both forthcoming games …

Salut! Sunderland: In a mood of optimism that you’d be up for this, or that you know someone who would do it, here are the questions:

Mark Barber: Optimism..?? Have you never heard of Typical City… we never take anything for granted…

What a time to be a City supporter. But do you ever miss the old days of the occasional good season surrounded by years of low achievement in United’s shadow?

Don’t miss the smugness of the United fans when we went through the 35 years of pain with no trophies, but football should be about two teams battling each other to win, so games where we beat a team 6-0 which their fans have travelled miles to watch and see how they can cope against our superstars makes me feel sorry for them. Don’t care though if we beat a supposed top 4 by a high score.


Following on from that, to what extent does City remain a proper football club as opposed to a brand?

City is the team of the people in Manchester, always has been, always will be. Whilst the hospitality section is getting bigger and the sponsors sell products none of us can afford, the ticket prices are still very reasonable and City Square (our pre game entertainment zone) keeps the club close to the working class fan and our web site is fantastic in the amount of information they share. The global brand is growing, especially with us buying an Australian team recently and setting up a new club in New York but all this will help increase our income without the need to put up prices

Jake: 'this trophy's beyond City' Mark: 'No, it's in the bag'

Jake: ‘this trophy’s beyond City’
Mark: ‘No, it’s in the bag’

Do you honestly believe City will make this a quadruple-winning season or will you have to settle for everything except the Capital One Cup?

It is the press that is talking about the quadruple, no City fan I speak with thinks we will do it this season. We are nervous that the press are putting us on a pedestal ready to knock us down as they like doing with any English success, so they will report that we only won… rather than congratulate us on any achievement. After 35 years of pain targeting one trophy a season is moving in the right direction for us. Personally I think we will win 2 of the 4. Sorry but I think the Capital One is ours, I don’t feel we are strong enough yet for Champions League but am really looking forward to watching us play Barcelona. The number of games we will be forced to play to win the FA Cup and Premier League makes me think that we will need to target one of those two rather than both.

City have had Francis Lee, Colin Bell and, to mention a couple of buys from SAFC, Dave Watson and Dennis Tueart, is good past squads. How do they shape up when compared with the current megastars?

I started watching City in 1976 so Francis Lee and King Colin in their prime was before my time. Dave Watson was a superb player in his time and Dennis Tueart a real fans favourite as he would spend a lot of his spare time meeting with us fans and always performed on the pitch. To compare to todays players is perhaps unfair but Kompany is such a skilful player for a Central Defender he has to be a better all round player than Dave and a great leader of the team. Silva v Tueart is not even a fair question, Silva is simply unbelievable in the way he can trap a ball and pass it in to space all in one movement.

Any abiding memories of others linked to Sunderland: Niall, Peter Reid, Claudio Reyna, Tony Coton and others, including – going way back – Tony Towers?

Not sure what we have done to upset Niall, he seems anti City in his commentary these days, he did very well for us in a team that wasn’t the strongest in the league. Reid was the leader we needed on the pitch to guide our youngsters and was a great manager for us, such a shame he could not get on with the owners…. For an American Claudio was certainly someone special and is now busy setting up our New York City Team a great choice by our owners to develop the Brand.. Tony Coton is one of many great goalkeepers we have had through the years, been ill in recent times so we all wish him good health for the future. Sorry never say Tony Towers.

The title-winning season and now are clearly highs for any City supporter but have there been others, less obvious ones?

The biggest high for any City fan was Dickov scoring in the 95th Minute against Gillingham in the playoff final, another season in the third tear of English Football could have been the start of the end for our club, instead that goal was the start of the new beginning. Our current owners would not have bought a low league team regardless of how good their stadium was…

And what have been the lows in your time as a fan? Last years loss to Wigan in the FA Cup Final was a real low, not because we just expected to win, but because our team of superstars just did not put in any real effort on the day. We can cope with losing as long as we try our best…

Jake calls for superhuman effort. Mark predicts 5-1 to ???

Jake calls for superhuman effort. Mark predicts 5-1 to ???


Tell us what it is really like to be able to be condescending about United.

It is actually causing me trouble. each time I drive past Old Trafford the Police stop me and issue a ticket, apparently all visitors to there leave with three points nowadays…

Do any games between our sides, home or away, stick especially in the mind?

No, Sunderland are a really bogey team for us, so never enjoy them, especially now you have Adam, he always ups his game against us.

I suspect you’re hoping we stay up if for no other reason so that you can hope one day to come to the Stadium of Light and not get beaten 1-0.

I think you will survive, there are some real bad teams below you and you have a good manager in charge now. You’re a team with strong links to City as you have mentioned in other questions, so one I always want to be in the top division.

So what will; be the top four in order and the bottom three?

For me the current top 4 will be the teams that finish there, but can’t predict the order of the top 3, Liverpool will finish 4th. My ideal would be City, Arsenal, Chelsea, Liverpool, but think it could be Chelsea, City, Arsenal, Liverpool. (Mark’s bottom three remains a closely guarded secret; his optimism about SAFC preceded the Hull game – ed)

What most inspires you about the modern game, and what appals?

The skills of the modern players are fantastic and the way they train to reach those standards can only inspire others… It’s such a shame that the atmosphere is so much quieter these days, without being able to stand with a fag in one hand, a pint in the other and a pie in your gob, whilst watching the game. I just can’t see those days coming back…

Brazil: does City’s array of stars from overseas make it the World Cup more interesting or are you too much of a club man to be bothered much?

As a proud English Man I can’t support any other team in the World Cup, we will supply the goalie and perhaps Milner in midfield, the rest of the English Team will be United and Southampton players, so hardly inspiring.

Will you be at our game and what will be the score?

Yes I will be there, at the back of Level one, in the corner of the South Stand and the Colin Bell Stand. Will be in City Square before the game too, make sure you try it out, very friendly area for both sets of fans to mix before the game. The score….?? We have been hurt by Chelsea so the team will want to put in a performance 5-1 With Adam J scoring the first goal for you.

Mark Barber

Mark Barber

* Mark Barber on himself: I am secretary of the Manchester City Disabled Supporters’ Association. Been supporting the team since 1976 with my first season ticket being in the 76/77 season. I had to give up my ticket for a long time as worked in retail management for 18 years so could not get Saturdays off work, but am now committed to the 9-5 so I can be back there on matchdays… Having become disabled through ill health in 1997 I decided I wanted to help other disabled people live active lives. As such I have done a lot of voluntary work encouraging disabled people to get out of the house and if possible back to work. My work at the MCDSA involves me writing the web site and newsletter and organising our meetings. I promote our members voluntary and charity activities and get many of them in front of their past heroes at our meetings. It is hard work but very rewarding and how smug do I feel with numerous ex-players phone numbers now stored in my mobile… If you’re reading this Niall or Peter, we would love to have you along… The family and friends of many of our members tell me how they have come out of a shell of depression and loneliness now they get to interact with the new friends they have made through our association and have something to look forward to each month. For more info visit our web site www.mcdsa.co.uk

Interview: Colin Randall


Join the Salut! Sunderland Facebook group – click anywhere along this line



And follow us on Twitter: @salutsunderland … click along this line

Click anywhere on this sentence for a glance at the home page – and highlights of all the most recent articles …

Jake flags the new feature allowing you to have your say on topic or off
Jake flags the new feature allowing you to have your say on topic or off

Fancy leaving a comment? Not sure what you have to say fits this post? Go to the new feature – http://salutsunderland.com/2013/07/s
Fancy leaving a comment? Not sure what you have to say fits this post? Go to the new feature – http://salutsunderland.com/2013/07/salut-sunderland-the-way-it-is/ – and say it there.

Tags: , , , , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

8 Responses to “Manchester City v Sunderland ‘Who are you?’: come back Niall and Reidy” Subscribe

  1. Drummer February 11, 2014 at 11:28 am #

    5-1 sir, how dare you! Seriously though I think of City supporters as similar to us in that they are true fans,unlike us who have a good owner they have won the lottery and have unlimited money from middle eastern oil wells till they run out.Hopefully they’ll be off colour Wednesday and distracted by bigger prizes for the final , well we can dream can’t we?

  2. Roddy February 11, 2014 at 2:43 pm #

    Manchester City vs Sunderland? Hardly a fair fight, but City will just have to take their chances.

    Seriously, an away match against a far superior team, provides the lads the perfect scenario: low expectations and thus zero pressure. I thoroughly expect them to perform out of their skins, with Johnson to score.

    Based on this season, if we can’t take major points from the top dogs in away matches, then where, in heaven’s name, do we expect to pick up points?

  3. William C February 11, 2014 at 3:30 pm #

    5-1? Not a hope. Seriously, poor as we have been, we rarely get tanked. I think we will nick it 1-0 again, maybe playing a bit like Fulham did against United on Sunday. But I do agree that Adam Johnson may score.

    Can’t agree that Kompany is better than Dave Watson either. It is well nigh impossible to compare players from different era’s, but pound for pound I’d go for Watson all day long. He [ DW ] was the best CH of his era by a country mile. IMO you couldn’t say that of Kompany. John Terry, for instance, is, in my opinion, still a better player.

    You can’t compare Silva and Tueart. Two players with totally different skills. However, I bet Dennis would get into City’s best 11 if he were playing these days?

  4. Andy Mac February 11, 2014 at 4:18 pm #

    Blue in peace.
    D.W. V VK.
    Loved bog Dave, epitomy of the centre half of his day, one of the best headers I’ve ever seen. Better than VK ?Not in my book as I don’t think Dave’s pace would keep up with modern internationals every week and his passing wasn’t anywhere near good enough.
    D.T. V D.S.
    Dennis was a massive favourite and stayed on to offer fantastic service after he retired. Silva is simply the 2nd best midfielder we’ve had in my time so a comparison isn’t that simple. Would Dennis get in the ‘all-time’ City side?no.
    In the present one ? he’d be a good sub possibly.
    Just my opinion, both will always be giants in my memory.

    • salutsunderland February 11, 2014 at 4:49 pm #

      Thanks Andy. I think fitness levels are a world apart these days, even if the technique – even if of a higher standard- is often a great deal less easy on the eye.

  5. Roddy February 11, 2014 at 5:42 pm #

    Funny isn’t it? I can remember my dad telling me in the ’60’s, that the then current Sunderland eleven were ‘rubbish’ compared to the teams of his youth, back in the 1930’s. And he meant it.

    He also confided, with a bit of a wink, that back in the day his own father used to chide him, that the ’30’s era Sunderland teams my dad idolized,were so poor, that Alf Common, in his day, could have dribbled through the entire team and scored at will.

    I suppose there will always be the age-old argument of which era players are better. To me the game seemed a lot more exciting and open, way back when. Then again, I am in my 60’s so…….

  6. Eric012 February 11, 2014 at 6:06 pm #

    I thought it was called the Bell End!

    • MCFC 1 February 11, 2014 at 6:40 pm #

      No haha, it’s on the side, not the end!
      As good as Watson was, Kompany’s passing & pace is far superior in my opinion.
      I’ve always liked Sunderland & the events on the final day in 2012 live long in the memory (Sunderland fans poznan to Utd fans).

      Hoping for a good game, hopefully City play to their potential though & play like they can.

      3-1 City.

Leave a Reply

Vito Mannone’s proud, emotional farewell to Sunderland as he joins Reading

And as the Countdown stalls at the first hurdle Benno is less than impressed with Don Vito's distribution..

The news that Vito Mannone was leaving came as Sunderland prepared for the friendly win at Hartlepool. In itself, it […]

West Ham Champions of the Premier League (table of season ticket affordability)

Salut Banner3(featured image)

  John McCormick writes: I get regular abuse banter from certain people who believe Anfield is a good value, top-class stadium. […]

Sixer’s Soapboax from Hartlepool: Grayson’s work in progress

Sixer's Soapbox (featured image)

M Salut writes: at a chilly Victoria Park last night, Pete Sixsmith took a good look at the 17 players […]

On Sunderland beating Hartlepool 2-1 and Mannone ‘heading for Reading’

Sixer's Sevens (featured image)

This is not really Sixer’s Sevens, much as it relies on Pete Sixsmith’s reflections from Victoria Park, where Sunderland’s pre-season […]

Birmingham, Wolves, Brentford, Forest, Cardiff, Preston, QPR and Ipswich go missing from our poll

McCormick's Craic(featured image) full size 640 x 138

I have to say I’m a bit surprised by the poll results to date. ‘Boro being top is reasonable. They […]

North of the border down Livingston way

Promotion at first attempt!

Malcolm Dawson writes……with Sixer, our normal match reporter recuperating in Wales after the early summer grind of exam marking, it […]