Jake: 'at least we gave them a fight'

Jake: ‘at least we gave them a fight’

Almost too late to be publishable, Keir Bradwell comes up with his man-by-man SAFC assessment of the New Year’s Day defeat at the Etihad. His intention was to combine that game and the Leeds FA Cup tie in a double header. But he was not at the cup match and there were no streams or TV coverage, hence what he terms ‘some phenomenally late ratings for Manchester City 3 – 2 Sunderland’ …

Pantilimon – 7
The only member of our ex-City trio not to score on the day, Pants made up for this disappointment by the means of a stellar goalkeeping performance in which three goals were conceded but none that you could blame our in-form Romanian for.

Vergini – 6

O’Shea – 7
One of the 11 or so men behind the ball in the first half, as part of Poyet’s innovative “park the Caterpillar 797” tactic, which worked resoundingly well until City scored three times.

Brown – 6
See Vergini. Customarily almost as good as John O’Shea.

Jones – 7
See O’Shea.

Rodwell – 8
YES. Scored a goal, and played very well. Hopefully helps to silence some of his critics. All we need now is for Jozy to do the same.

Larsson – 7
Another typical, hard working, set piece delivering Larsson performance. Looks a bit tired though.

Gomez – 3
As I have explained in previous weeks, I’m not a huge Gomez fan.

Buckley – 3
HE’S DONE IT! Finally, someone has mastered the art of invisibility. Since this whole football thing isn’t working out, he should become a magician.

Wickham – 6

Johnson – 6
Got a lot more involved than Buckley, which was nice. Starting to perform consistently, which is encouraging to see.


Giaccherini – 7
Runs at the opposition pace with actual threat. Never seen anything like it.

Alvarez – 7
Uses skill to weave his way into the opposition box. Never seen anything like it.

Coates – 4
Didn’t really notice him.

Jake: 'late with your homework again, son? See me'

Jake: ‘late with your homework again, son? See me’

Tags: , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

One Response to “Keir’s Sunderland Player Ratings: ‘Rodwell my star at Manchester City’” Subscribe

  1. Jeremy January 5, 2015 at 8:08 pm #

    So Pantilimon is only worth a point more than Wickham?

Leave a Reply

World Cup Diaries: (4) Moscow en fête as Russians celebrate another big win

Andy Falconer: 'I love Sunderland really'

Our Boro-suppporting World Cup diarist – Monsieur Salut’s nephew, Andy Falconer – changes city. After revealing in the beauty of […]

Sunderland’s Spanish conquest: ‘the essence of English football in its purest sense’

Jake: 'when will we next see sunny times for Sunderland AFC?'

This well-researched and, for Sunderland fans, heartwarming slice of football history was written by David Hewitt, a PhD researcher in […]

The Paddy McNair question and the ins and outs of squad rebuilding at Sunderland

One that was made earlier. Nic, left, with Claire, from outside the Fulwell

This tweet, from a Twitter contact (we follow each other), caught the attention. Well Mr Paddy McNair I do not […]

World Cup Diaries: (3) our Middlesbrough-supporting chronicler enjoys his first game

Andy Falconer: 'I love Sunderland really'

This is the third instalment of the World Cup musings of Monsieur Salut’s Boro-supporting nephew, Andy Falconer, who saves hard-earned […]

The Beautiful Game? Wrinkly Pete’s thoughts on the power of football

Wrinkly Pete(featured image)

John McCormick writes: We’re not the only old and famous club to be facing turbulent times and I’m sure our […]

Strangely Unmoved. What World Cup?

McCormick's Craic(featured image) full size 640 x 138

When Colin put up his competition about prediciting the World Cup finalists I had a go.  I chose England because […]