As we all know, the Tyne-Wear derby is more than just a question of whether SAFC can make it seven wins in a row. Premier League survival could depend on the outcome.

Steve McClaren has gone. The unprofessionalism he showed in handling the media in the death throes of his Newcastle United managerial career may have been caused by the stress of knowing the axe was poised above his head, so maybe he deserves our sympathy.

And the smart money – only money – is on Rafa Benitez, another manager with a history of strops with the press, to replace him. He may find St James’ Park “less sexy than Real” according to a Belgian site I came across, but we can hardly say he’s a useless manager.

The derby result is not, of course, the only one that matters in what seems to have become a fight for fourth bottom. There remains the case of Norwich City, whose forthcoming home games against both NUFC and SAFC would seem to hand them an advantage as they contemplate their own prospects of ending up the one club among the other three to stay up.

Then again, if both Norwich and the Mags lose on a weekend when we have no game (likely on form with the Canaries at the Etihad and Newcastle visiting Leicester, but perhaps we should be prepared for at least one shock), Sunderland’s hopes will be brighter.

Aston Villa appear to be down already. But are there Villa fans out there who believe they can still pull off a Leicester-style great escape? Can Bournemouth, Swansea of Crystal Palace even now be dragged into the scrap?

I cannot really call this poll just for fun since there is little fun involved in what has become for us an annual ritual.

But just for the heck of it (as in no prize), let us see your vote on which of the two North East Premier managers, Big Sam or – assuming the speculation is well-founded – Benitez you would rather have leading your troops in such a desperate battle.

First vote cast was Monsieur Salut’s. For Big Sam. Ha’way the Lads.

M Salut, drawn by Matt, colouring by Jake

M Salut, drawn by Matt, colouring by Jake

Tags: , , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

One Response to “Sunderland, Newcastle, Norwich, Aston Villa. Whose manager is best suited to task?” Subscribe

  1. ianoklahoma March 11, 2016 at 11:37 pm #

    Benitez is not one of the elite foreign managers,he’s won a few cups,but he has never been in a relegation scrap and I don’t think he will enjoy what he has to come.I never rated him much and I still think that Villa,at the moment they are total crap,the Mags are no better and Norwich are playing poorly and their manager has no more ideas on how to win crucial games that they are about to face,they will go down.As for us,we are playing decent football now and I am confident we can get the points we need to stay up,plus we have Big Sam and i’m sure he will tell them how to play in the final games in no uncertain manner!

Leave a Reply

Beyond belief: the football club owner who has never spoken to his manager

Jake: 'you don't talk to the likes of us, Ellis, so how can we be blamed if we get somethign wrong?

Welcome to the strange world of Ellis Short, reluctant and reclusive football boss. In the past, Salut! Sunderland may have […]

A Daughter Speaks: how Wigan and Rochdale restored the FA Cup’s shine

Footy loving Nathalie is second from the left

Amid all Sunderland’s more pressing problems, it seems almost incidental to reflect on how old you now have to be […]

SAFC vs Middlesbrough Who are You?: ‘Coleman’s great but what a mountain to climb’

We were both in the Premier League when Jake came up with this banner for the game (we lost 2-1) that prompted David Moyes's infamous relegation scrap comments

Monsieur Salut writes: having used up virtually the entire Boro-supporting side of my family (my sister has lived there throughout […]

Post-Bolton thoughts: as Brian Clough said…

McCormick's Craic(featured image) full size 640 x 138

By now you’ll have read Pete Sixsmith’s report from Bolton. I can’t find fault with it and there’s no point in […]

Sixer’s Bolton Soapbox: Sunderland lacking up front after going behind

Sixer's Soapbox (featured image)

John McCormick writes: the only pleasure associated with last night was that I met up with Pete Sixsmith and Pete […]

Chroniclers of doom. Where, Ellis Short, will SAFC be a year hence?

what's going on, Ellis?
Photo courtesy of safc.com

Gloomy times, gloomy thoughts from Monsieur Salut … No football club, whatever its history, has a divine right to play […]