Paul Summerside hoping for calmer waters - and a new man on the bridge

Paul Summerside hoping for calmer waters – and a new man on the bridge


Monsieur Salut presented
a brief argument in favour of sticking with David Moyes at this link. Rob Hutchison has already made the case more strongly here

We both knew our views would be controversial. And so it has proved. Some good, robust replies point legitimately to shortcomings in Moyes’s brief reign.

Paul Summerside also chipped in, at Salut! Sunderland‘s Facebook pages. This is what he had to say:

While I admire your loyalty and understand the argument for stability, I cannot agree.

Loyalty should be given only to those who have earned it, and stability can be assured only if results and a safe league position are established. Neither of these apply to David Moyes.

Your four points* for removing him far outweigh the four points* for keeping him, the Jones/Khazri substitution being the clincher for me. Genuinely clueless.

David Moyes WILL take us down unless this situation is changed.

We don’t have the natural championship squad of Norwich, or the £90 million through sale of players to buy one like Newcastle. I don’t see us being able to bounce back in one season.

We must therefore survive again at all costs, and ensure the next appointment is based on quality, as well as availability.

Based on this the inevitable will happen, with only wins v Southampton, Arsenal and Hull able to save David Moyes.

* These were the 4 vs 4 pros and cons set out in the earlier piece by M Salut:

The questions we all feel entitled to raise about Moyes’s brief time at Sunderland are serious ones:

* how can any Premier League manager go nine games without a win and expect to keep his job?

* why did Moyes start talking down our season’s prospects as early as the second game (1-2 at home to Boro)?

* was the purchase of McNair and Love for a total of £5m really more sensible, on any level, than bringing back Yann M’Vila in spite of Rubin Kazan’s reportedly outrageous financial demands for a player who will be out of contract in January?

* Where was the sense in sending on Billy Jones for Wahbi Khazri with just minutes left at West Ham with the home side looking only marginally more likely than the visitors to snatch victory?

At a guess, Moyes’s replies would not require the assistance of Victor Anichebe’s social media manager. How about …

* I was at a disadvantage
from the start, my appointment scandalously delayed by the FA’s dithering over Allardyce. All other Premier clubs had a good start on me in terms of acquiring new players

* I was being realistic and probably saying no more, and perhaps a lot less, than the man in the Sunderland pub

* I do not hold the purse strings. Ask the chairman or CEO

* Ask any manager of a struggling side what he would do in the same circumstances and needing to try to take something from the game

The debate is still open to all …

Tags: , , , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

2 Responses to “You’ve seen the Remain case for Moyes. Now hear from a Leaver” Subscribe

  1. Salutsunderland October 26, 2016 at 4:56 pm #

    I wish we’d never lost Sam and don’t actually think his obvious greed matters that much in a greedy society, however regrettable it may be. But I just feel we need not so much stability (which for us means an annual relegation scare) but continuity. Bringing in troubleshooters for a miracle cure when the cause looks lost has worked only in delivering the immediate fix. All but one – Keane, O’Neill, Di Canio, Poyet, Advocaat and Sam – have done the rescue bit only to be unable to develop or even sustain. Bruce is the odd one out but also showed in the end, alarming signs of not being up to the task (after having the best season since Reid, 10th top). Without the least enthusiasm, I feel Moyes – having proved himself in his main managerial job – must be given two years to see if that rare concept, time, can at last break this grim cycle of wretched football, grim results and a flash of survival excitement.

  2. Bill Taylor October 26, 2016 at 5:17 pm #

    Remember how we used to complain about Steve Bruce? From this distance, he no longer looks quite as dire…

Leave a Reply

Sunderland’s 10 relegations: The Coventry conundrum (part 2)

Sixer'sSoapbox(featured image)

John McCormick writes: I was there, at Goodison, that night. For a long time afterwards I felt cheated but I […]

Things for fans to do until Sunderland’s football season starts in August

Jake: 'would winning the last four games just make us angrier?'

After a season like that, it may seem a stretch of even the most fevered imagination to suppose Sunderland supporters […]

Who ate all the pies? And which club serves the best?

Just a few of Jake's generic Salut! Sunderland images ...

Monsieur Salut writes: what is it about football and pies? Things many of us rarely eat in normal, civilised settings […]

A daughter writes: amid the grief, a good night for Manchester

Nathalie, left, and team-mates in women's football. They get exasperated watching us play

Nathalie Randall is Monsieur Salut’s younger daughter. She plays football better than he ever did and tries to make up […]

Sunderland’s 10 relegations: the Coventry City conundrum (part one)

Pete Sixsmith: 'you know I'm getting used to see the Lads beaten'

  Monsieur Salut writes: scroll down on the right of this article and you’ll find him: the perplexed Coventry fan […]

End of season reviews: (3) smilin’ like I’m happy, seeking extenuating circumstances

Jake: 'would winning the last four games just make us angrier?'

Colin Randall writes: I commend this epic piece from our associate editor John McCormick, his superbly argued but also entertaining […]