no slide rule needed

Let’s go back to the start of the season (and don’t we wish we could).

I polled our readers as to who would make the top six. These clubs came up favourite ( in the order given) and I began tracking them and reporting on their progress from time to time:

Middlesbrough

Aston Villa

Fulham

Sheffield Wednesday

Leeds

and Sunderland

By Christmas, if not earlier, it was obvious some changes were needed.

Consequently, I did some new polls at the end of January, timed to coincide with the closure of the transfer window.

Two of the polls concerned clubs that had dropped out of the running and didn’t look like they’d ever get back. In January Sheffield Wednesday were in seventeenth place. Would they stay there?

                                       Where will Sheffield Wednesday finish?

Few people thought so but that’s where they still are, and that’s where they’ve been every time I’ve looked since the window shut. What’s more, looking at the points above and below them it looks like that’s where they’ll be staying for the immediate future.

I also asked you what you thought about Sunderland – would we stay up?

will Sunderland stay up? Poll results Jan 31, 2018

Just over half – 56% – of respondents said we would. I wonder what that figure is now.

More importantly, perhaps, I asked who you thought would get straight promotion.

Wolves, deservedly, were clear favourites, with Derby and Villa some distance behind. Then came Sheffield United and Bristol City, followed by Fulham, Cardiff and Leeds. Boro and “other” were also available categories but neither gained any votes:

                 Who will win straight promotion?

Then I asked you who would make the playoffs:

                                              who will make the playoffs?

This time Wolves, no doubt because of their prominence, were being discounted (but only for the playoffs), Cardiff, who weren’t fancied much for straight promotion, were streets ahead when it came to making it. In between were eight clubs. Boro, originally clear favourites to go straight up, weren’t in the running and Leeds and Brentford garnered even fewer votes (and one person voted for “other “ but never said which club they meant). There wasn’t much between the other six – not that the number of votes was anything like the start of season poll.

I was thinking on the lines of removing about three of the original clubs and slotting in perhaps three new ones, and it wasn’t working out. Slimming down the list would make my graphs easier to follow but it would mean arbitrarily excluding some of the clubs that had done as well as others in the January poll.

I decided that I didn’t need to exclude Leeds, Sheffield Wednesday or Sunderland – they weren’t going to get in the way of the rest. Brentford, I mused, didn’t have enough votes to merit inclusion, and I’d have to ignore that single “other”. That left a potential five clubs to add – perhaps too far away from my original idea because of the clutter too many clubs would create.

Would my chart following the progress of our chosen clubs be easy to follow if I added Wolves, Cardiff, Bristol, Derby and Sheffield United? Well, I added them, and  you can see what I got tomorrow.

 

Jake: looking back

 Reading at last? Norwich perhaps, or Derby, Leeds, ‘Boro and Sheffield? What’s your fancy?
 Middlesbrough, Aston Villa, Fulham, Sheff Wed, Leeds and Sunderland – the ones to watch
 Wolves and Derby? Or Villa and Cardiff? Leeds, Boro and Fulham for the playoffs? Bristol City and Sheffield United might say no.

 

If you can bear to look, clicking the image leads to the Salut! Sunderland home page

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Sixer’s Walsall Sevens: Third time unlucky? Maybe not.

Jake

Pete Sixsmith may be busy on the Saturdays before Christmas but on the weekdays he leaves the work to his […]

Rate the ref: Walsall at home, FA cup replay

Rate The Ref featured image

Our first home game since the series started. We don’t expect many ratings for away games but we should get […]

Walsall Who are You: Sunderland ‘pretty useful going forward, less convincing off the ball’

se

Monsieur Salut writes: this is a Who are You? with a difference ahead of tonight’s FA Cup 2nd round replay […]

Salut advent calendar: what strange goings on lie behind door 11?

In the run up to Christmas Day, behind each door of the Salut! Sunderland advent calendar is an article written […]

Wham: Going ballistic at Accrington Stanley

McCormick's Craic(featured image) full size 640 x 138

There has been a bit of discussion on the calling off and whether (no pun intended) it was or wasn’t […]

Sixer’s Substitute’s Soapbox: a wet weekend in Accrington

Sixer's Soapbox (featured image)

Jake: ‘that wasn’t in the script’ Play this and read on!LA = Lancashire – Accrington Malcolm Dawson writes…….there was a […]

Page generated in 1.046 seconds. Stats plugin by www.blog.ca