Well said, Jake

Three references to the approach some Sunderland supporters adopt towards their club caught the eye yesterday and today, says Monsieur Salut.

First, as most readers will have seen, several important points were made in Pete Sixsmith’s typically measured and intelligent report on the 1-1 draw at Luton Town.

It’s a great read in its entirety but this passage leapt from the page:

Some in the crowd and on the message boards, criticise Maja for not being strong enough, which is a bit like criticising an apple for not tasting like an orange. He is not a physical player (yet) but he is very good at getting himself between the ball and an opponent and won a number of free kicks because of this. Some of our supporters need to realise that he is young and is still learning. Two good goals in two hard games is a pretty decent record.

Then I came across two items at Facebook, each making essentially the same point (while also fleshing out Pete’s more specific one).

Paul Summerside, an occasionally contributor here and much more often at Salut! Sunderland’s Facebook group, wrote:

As from today I have stopped following ALL SAFC Fanzines online. I’m sick and tired of the constant drivel from some of our ‘fans’. It’s borderline dross. From now on I’ll be quite happy with Nick Barnes, Salut!, and the opinions of my ‘real’ friends.

The praise for this site is appreciated but not the reason I reproduce Paul’s words. The BBC Newcastle matchday commentator Nick Barnes, also mentioned with approval, echoed his view:

I’m minded to come off Facebook – can’t believe the negativity surrounding the draw at Luton. Sunderland are League One with a largely League One team. No divine right to beat everyone else in the division. They are a work in progress and unbeaten. I despair

The responses in all cases are welcome.

Nick’s posting has attracted 137 “likes” (as I write) and Pete Sixsmith, among the many leaving comments, said: “It was a good result against a good side. I despair at times: some of those stood near me were much happier criticising than praising. The sh**** word is becoming overused.”

Paul’s posting has generated some good debate, too. Ed Tutty offered this: “On a wider note, this is what is wrong with social media in general. Keyboard warriors who feel their voice needs to be heard. Very rare that I look at fans’ forums on any sport for this reason.”

What it boils down to is this. Sunderland supporters are entitled to be angry as well as saddened at what has happened in the past couple of season (and much of what happened before that). There is no law, thanks heavens, against expressing opinions, even robustly, provided this does not breach sensible restrictions on hatred and incitement.

But two games into a season after beginning a root-and-branch overhaul of an ailing club, Jack Ross deserves our backing. Constructive criticism is legitimate. But absolutely nothing positive will be gained from belittling or barracking our own players, individually or collectively, at the game or online.

Happily, my guess is that what has incensed Pete, Nick and Paul is limited to a small but loud-mouthed minority.

Tags: ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

3 Responses to “After a four-point start to the season, it is time for the carping to stop?” Subscribe

  1. Rutland Mike August 13, 2018 at 10:28 am #

    Some supporters, albeit a minority, still have a sense of entitlement, despite the reality check of successive relegations. The journey on the road to recovery must begin with small steps and, doubtless, there will be the odd mishap on the way, but four points secured from two matches with a new squad missing key injured players is a promising start,

  2. David August 13, 2018 at 10:47 am #

    There are so many positives for us now that there is absolutely no need for negativity.
    I’d like to state that I’m 100% behind the new owners, managerial staff and all our players, excited by the way the season is unfolding and happy to be a cheerful charlie.

  3. Jeremy August 13, 2018 at 7:49 pm #

    With 4-6 players who are probably starters when fit and what is largely a new team, 4 points is a very good start. We will get better as the players learn to understand one another better and gel as a unit. Far more reasons to be cheerful than not.

Leave a Reply

Rate the ref: Scunthorpe v Sunderland

Rate The Ref featured image

In an attempt to minimise RSI I’m reducing the page to the poll and little more. I’ll set up a […]

Sixer’s Scunthorpe Sevens: A good point but we need to find that poacher

Sixer's Sevens (featured image)

What do you make of a draw at Scunny? A point gained or two thrown away? Luton open a gap, […]

The First Time Ever I Saw Your Ground: Scunthorpe United and Glanford Park

Salut Banner5(featured image)

It’s over 100 years since E M Forster wrote “The Machine Stops”. If you haven’t read it I suggest you […]

View from the Avenue: a Sunderland rallying cry to still half-term wobbles

Jake: 'when will we next see sunny times for Sunderland AFC?'

Monsieur Salut says: Paul Summerside and I joust regularly at Facebook about Brexit, a subject I broadly feel wisest to […]

French Fancies: ‘star chroniclers’ Henry Winter, Sam Wallace and tenuous Sunderland links

Salut Banner2(featured image)

France’s leading Sunday newspaper hails four stars of Premier League football writing[/caption] How can I make this sound like it […]

Scunthorpe vs SAFC prize Guess the Score: make Rod Liddle eat his words

Scunthorpe A

Monsieur Salut introduces the latest prize Guess the Score competition. Don’t worry if your entry is ‘held for moderation’ – […]

Page generated in 1.040 seconds. Stats plugin by www.blog.ca