Ken Gambles: let’s hear it for – and against – the man with the whistle

John McCormick writes: Ken Gambles posed an interesting problem on Thursday. How do we rate refereeing? More explicitly, How do we rate refereeing in League One?

A few of our readers liked his idea and the 10 point scale he suggested so we’ve decided to give it a go.

You’ll find a poll below. All you need do is pick the description which you think best fits today’s ref.

Scores will be collated and reported from time to time – We’re not sure how, yet, but it will be on the lines of a monthly leaderboard and then an end of season summary.

We’ve also decided to make the ratings visible as they are entered. This has led to problems in the past because flaws in the poll coding, which we can’t change, mean a lot of modern browsers and operating systems ignore the block on multiple voting.

We don’t think anyone will abuse this flaw but if you want to enter multiple votes, (like the Coventry Ninjas did) you can. We won’t try stop you, but we will wonder what kind of saddo you are if you’re not the ref or one of his family. (And even then we’ll wonder why you’d bother).

And if you want to add a comment that would be great, as would letting us know if you’re an away supporter or a neutral fan. Anyone posting for the first time will find their comment is held for moderation but we get there eventually.
By
Supporters of both clubs can enter, and we’d prefer it if people who hadn’t seen the whole game didn’t vote, given that thirty seconds of EFL transmission on Quest TV hardly allows a judgement. The poll will be up for a day or two, which should give you time to get back from the game, calm down, have a beer, have a wee, calm down a bit more, take a deep breath and make sure you really have calmed down before you give us your cool, honest, objective appraisal. Or maybe it won’t:

Here’s the poll:

 

 

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

2 Responses to “Ken’s Kategories: Your chance to rate the ref at Walsall” Subscribe

  1. George December 1, 2018 at 9:04 pm #

    Realistically it’s probably for home games where there will be a response to the refereeing. But we’ll wait and see. I went last week but didn’t fancy another 13 hours of travelling.

  2. malcolm December 1, 2018 at 9:33 pm #

    Just back after 4 hour drive each way. Glad I went, wish I hadn’t bothered with the thermals though.

    Thought the ref was OK. Better than last week’s by a mile.

    PS anyone know why Loovens wasn’t on the bench again? He wasn’t there on Tuesday either but haven’t seen why.

Leave a Reply

Bristol Rovers Who are You?: ‘only one team in Bristol, isn’t there?’

Click Jake's image to see all Who are You? instalments so far this season

The curse of Who are You? A frantic call from Doug tells M Salut the manager has left today ‘by […]

Salut! Sunderland’s advent calendar day 13 – how unlucky can you get?

Salut Banner5(featured image)

In the run up to Christmas Day, behind each door of the Salut! Sunderland advent calendar is an article written […]

Sixer’s Sub’s Walsall Soapbox: Saddlers unseat Sunderland in FA Cup exit

Sixer'sSoapbox(featured image)

Malcolm Dawson writes……. Pete Sixsmith is usually very busy at this time of year, and although he was at the […]

SAFC vs Bristol Rovers prize Guess the Score: no more slips, please

Jake: 'wipe away the Walsall blues'

To listen to my Bristol Rovers-supporting or Bristol-dwelling friends and acquaintances, Sunderland vs Rovers is the mother of all home […]

Rate the ref: Walsall at home, FA cup replay

Rate The Ref featured image

Our first home game since the series started. We don’t expect many ratings for away games but we should get […]

Walsall Who are You: Sunderland ‘pretty useful going forward, less convincing off the ball’

se

Monsieur Salut writes: this is a Who are You? with a difference ahead of tonight’s FA Cup 2nd round replay […]

Page generated in 1.488 seconds. Stats plugin by www.blog.ca