Archive | Keir’s Player Ratings RSS feed for this section

Keir’s Sunderland Player Ratings: Wickham stars but West Ham snatch it

Jake: 'this is the place where you find true support, unconditional commitment'

Monsieur Salut writes: whatever is to blame – school work, family obligations, a games console – Keir Bradwell has been quiet of late. Remember: he’s the one who does the Sunderland ratings at greater length than Rob Hutchison. Well, he’s back to entertain or irritate, according to taste; I feel he is hard on Fletcher, […]

Read More 2 Comments

Masochism (2): Sunderland’s player ratings vs QPR. ‘Worse than Norwich away’

Jake's reaction echoed that friend of Sixer's: 'why am I not surprised?

If you thought Rob Hutchison was harsh with his one-word verdicts and low player ratings after the shambles of last night, prepare to reconsider. Rob was positively benign compared with Keir Bradwell, who cannot bring himself to award higher than an average of 3/10 for the starting 11. Keir uses that infamous defeat at Norwich […]

Read More 15 Comments

Keir’s Player Ratings and QPR Guess the Score

Jake: 'forget the mugs: Monsieur Salut has a better class of prize these days'

Apologies to all for pulling these two items together, a necessity given constraints on time between the two games, at Swansea on Saturday and at home to QPR tomorrow. Agree or disagree with Keir Bradwell’s man-by-man ratings from the 1-1 draw at the Liberty Stadium and then have a stab at the scoreline in tomorrow’s […]

Read More 12 Comments

Keir’s ratings: Burnley and Fulham – who’s good? Who’s best?

Keir Bradwell

  John McCormick writes: In the 1960s, when most of the Salut team had just graduated from short pants, about 80,000 people a year got 5 or more O levels, an achievement which was guaranteed to impress not only Grandma but also employers. Now almost 80,000 people are awarded First Class Honours every year. By […]

Read More 1 Comment

Keir’s Sunderland Player Ratings: ‘Rodwell my star at Manchester City’

salut new

Almost too late to be publishable, Keir Bradwell comes up with his man-by-man SAFC assessment of the New Year’s Day defeat at the Etihad. His intention was to combine that game and the Leeds FA Cup tie in a double header. But he was not at the cup match and there were no streams or […]

Read More 1 Comment

Keir’s Aston Villa player ratings. Not impressed

Jake says you are now entering a goal free zone

Nic Wiseman writes: Young Keir Bradwell has obviously been feasting on bah humbugs as he penned these ratings and most players seem to enrage him on Sunday’s performance. Do you agree with him, please let us know: Aston Villa 0 – 0 Sunderland: Player Ratings Pantilimon – 7 A quiet, assured game from our number […]

Read More 1 Comment

Keir’s SAFC vs Hull ratings: 67/140. Must do better

Jake: have your say on Keir's assessments

John McCormick writes: It being almost half-term and Keir providing numbers, I thought I’d sum things up in a succinct headline, like the ones I used to get some forty years ago. Maybe M Salut will change it but, for me, it says all we need to know. For a little more detail and individual […]

Read More 0 Comments

The return of Keir’s Player Ratings: Seb’s his star against West Ham

Jake: 'but will this work for us?'

Sunderland 1 – 1 West Ham: Player Ratings After being silenced by family commitments – and perhaps a spot of homework from school – young Keir Bradwell returns belatedly to action with his Sunderland ratings from the West Ham game (sorry Hammers, our players only; if I were marking yours, Song would be the star […]

Read More 0 Comments

Keir’s Everton player ratings. Things getting better

Keir Bradwell

Keir Bradwell has been quick off the mark today, as has his editor, Nic Wiseman. A good performance has resulted in good ratings for most of the squad: Sunderland 1 – 1 Everton Pantilimon – 8 Outstanding. He might have done better for their goal, but other than that, he was brilliant. Definitely deserves to […]

Read More 6 Comments

Keir’s Crystal Palace ratings – heading upwards apart from…..

Keir Bradwell

Keir Bradwell sends his apologies. He’s been busy of late but much better late than never are his ratings from Monday night, and it’s pleasing to see they’re mostly on the good side of five: (more…)

Read More 4 Comments

The First Time Ever I Saw Your Ground (with or without Sunderland): Carlisle United

Jake:  Sixer and Sobs expect to smile more next season

Brunton Park is the latest stop in Pete Sixsmith‘s series* looking at his own earliest experiences of the teams Sunderland […]

Carlisle Who are You? ‘when Shankly said ours was football’s greatest achievement’

Jake: 'let's be having you'

Colin Randall writes: our Carlisle United interviewee Mike Booth, a moderator at the Carlisle fans’ forum thecumbrians.net, says most people […]

Carlisle United vs SAFC Guess the Score: a winning bounceback after Leeds?

Jake kicks off a new season of Guess the Score

Monsieur Salut confesses: thank heavens no one went for Sunderland 0-2 Leeds. There are quite enough people who could tell […]

Sixer’s Leeds United Soapbox: ‘finish above this lot and SAFC go up’

Sixer's Soapbox (featured image)

Pete Sixsmith had almost forgotten what it was like to have to churn out, week after week, doom-laden masterpieces combining […]

Sixer’s Sevens: SAFC 0 Leeds United 2 – early season promise arrested by the boys in blue

Sixer's Sevens (featured image)

We’ve seen it before of course. A great chance to take the lead is cleared off the line and almost […]

The Sunderland AFC collection: fine art prints for Black Cats fans

The Salut! Sunderland Facebook group

Malcolm Dawson writes…..like most websites Salut! Sunderland gets approached from time to time to plug various commercial enterprises and whilst […]