The Hammers Soapbox: Carling Cup hopes gone west

Not a great night: out pf the Carling Cup at an early stage in front of a measly crowd for an all-Premier clash, then Titus Bramble arrested on suspicion of rape (though remember he’s innocent until proved otherwise, a concept that should commend itself to bigwigs at a certain association football club). A jury can sort out that one and low gates are sadly par for the Carling course. As for our flat performance, here is Pete Sixsmith‘s analysis …


I had
two possibilities for last night’s seven-word summary. The one that appeared was relevant to the disappointing performance we had turned in against a West Ham side who looked anything but relegation candidates. The other one will stay on my phone so I can recycle it if we are knocked out of the FA Cup by the likes of Bolton or Portsmouth.

It read “Typical Sunderland: programmed to let you down” and that just about sums up last night.

As soon as Steve Bruce made it clear that he thought we had a chance of winning the Carling Cup, there was a feeling in the pit of my not insubstantial stomach that it would all go wrong.

It did. The team were as far away from the level of performance achieved on Saturday as Ann Widdecombe is likely to be from that of Ginger Rogers.

On Saturday we were crisp and sharp; last night we were limp and flat. On Saturday we controlled the midfield for a lengthy period; last night we surrendered that area to the excellent Scott Parker and Radovan Kovac.

It was a strong team. Bardsley and Gyan came in for Bramble and Malbranque with Onuoha switching to centre half and Gyan linking with Bent. Bruce resisted the temptation to give starts to Zenden, Colback and Reid, believing that this was a winnable game in a winnable competition.

That it turned out to be anything but is a problem. Were we exhausted after Saturday’s exertions? Were minds fixed on Saturday’s visit to relegation strugglers Liverpool? Were West Ham seen as a push over? Whatever it was, we turned in the kind of performance guaranteed to have fans and managers howling at the moon in frustration.

Mignolet and Bardsley were the pick of our performers. The young Belgian looks very, very good and full marks to our scouting system for picking him up. Bardsley’s distribution is, and always will be, poor, but he never stops and he seemed to be the only player prepared to run at the Hammers in the closing stages.

Of the rest, Riveros faded badly after a decent start and needs time to adjust to the intensity of Premier League football. Welbeck was disappointing, continually falling over his own feet or standing still when the ball was played for him to run on to. He has spent all his career surrounded by success and needs to readjust to the perpetual disappointment that SAFC throws up.

Ferdinand, Gyan and Richardson all picked up knocks and had “hamstring tweaks”. Ferdinand and Bruce still don’t look to be the best of pals and ignored each other as the former Hammer limped off. Anton’s Indian Summer may be coming to an end.

As for West Ham, they looked a decent side. They controlled the midfield and the two men up front looked as if they will score goals. Both netted last night and both came when they were smart enough to get round the back of our rather flat and static back four.

Defensively they looked solid, with Ben Haim winning his own personal Yom Kippur War with Elmohamady and Da Costa and Collins (oops: see comments) subduing Bent and Gyan. They have a couple of important games coming up and if they can win at least one of them, they should start to climb the league. Decent turn out from their fans as well and I am sure that Sam the Hammer enjoyed himself.

So, Anfield next and another club giving a decent impression of being in a crisis. Cattermole is certain to be back, hopefully for 90 minutes and I can see a change in the middle of the back four. Maybe Mensah, just in case Torres decides to stir himself. We shall see.

Tags: , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

5 Responses to “The Hammers Soapbox: Carling Cup hopes gone west” Subscribe

  1. Sam H September 22, 2010 at 5:00 pm #

    I think we took about 800-1000 and for a tuesday night carling cup 3rd round tie, that really is quite amazing!

    I’ve known many top flight club – Wigan, Bolton, Fulham – to sometimes not even take that many to a Saturday afternoon league game

    I think it was said that Wigan took 47 to our place for our 6-pointer at the tail end of last season.

    Wow. Credit to the league.

  2. Bill Taylor September 22, 2010 at 5:25 pm #

    When’s the last time anyone was able to say of West Ham: “Defensively, they looked solid….”? This game could be the turning point for them. A shame it came at our expense, though.
    I’ll take a player any time like Bardsley, who never stops running, over someone with better skills but no inclination to work for 90 minutes. I’m hoping (not very optimistically) that Cattermole works at least twice as hard as usual on Saturday to make up for all the time he’s spent off the field.

  3. john clowthing September 22, 2010 at 6:14 pm #

    De Costa and Tompkins! Collins is at Villa now mate more’s the pity!

  4. Martin September 22, 2010 at 6:32 pm #

    It seems to me that they simply weren’t “up for it”. The evidence is there once more that we’re only going to show up for the big games. No offence to West Ham – they played well, but we had no intention whatsoever of playing with the same intensity as we did on Saturday. I am a big Steve Bruce supporter, but I have one concern about him. Can he motivate players to perform to their max in every game?? At the moment it seems not. Can anyone imagine a player playing under Brian Clough or Alex Ferguson stepping their foot off the gas in the way our mob did last night?!!

  5. Pete Sixsmith September 23, 2010 at 1:14 am #

    Sorry, John. Careless error. I thought Tompkins did well. Now do us a favour and knock the Mags out. It’s going to be an insufferable few days!!!

Leave a Reply

Wycombe Wanderers vs Sunderland: a good one to win from ninth place

Click on the image above, post your scoreline prediction and - whoever you support - you may win a prize

At first glance, the League one table makes for depressing perusal. Sunderland and down to ninth and are now eight […]

Ross In. A dignified but incisive valedictory: ‘I leave with head held high’

Jake: 'why not, with so many players with SAFC connections in Russia?'

A lot of Salut! Sunderland readers go nowhere near Twitter and as one who spends far too much time there, […]

Sunderland’s lengthening list of promotion rivals: Ipswich, plus Rotherham, Peterborough, Portsmouth and Doncaster (or Wycombe, Fleetwood, Blackpool and Coventry)

McCormick's Craic(featured image) full size 640 x 138

Another weekend without football, another weekend providing space to keep our readers – and pundits – up to date with […]

Sixer’s Grimsby Town Soapbox: never too early to start up the buses for Wembley

SOAPBOX (featured image)

Malcolm Dawson writes….I was busy last night with what laughingly passes for the only work I do since retirement. Laughingly, […]

Page generated in 2.944 seconds. Stats plugin by www.blog.ca