Reviews of the Season: blaming the owner, managers, players – and fans

Jake: Wrinkly Pete dips into the record collection again'

Jake: Wrinkly Pete dips into the record collection again’

After the excitement tension and ultimate relief of last Wednesday comes a time for cool reflection. Sunderland didn’t peer once again over the precipice because of rank bad luck. Survival was a close-run thing and we need to consider why there was yet another desperate battle for dear life in the last few games. Peter Lynn has some answers some will find spot-on, others a bit too finger-pointing. See the full End of Season Review series at

“It’s such a cryin’ shame, please tell me who’s to blame.”

Understandably, we are all thrilled
to have escaped relegation and it feels almost sacrilegious to be doing anything but celebrate.

However, rather than get carried away by the euphoria created by a draw at the Emirates, I would like to reflect on why we flirt with relegation virtually every season.

So, if you have access to Van Morrison’s Back on Top album, select track eight and play New Biography and listen out for the lyrics above in the five minutes it will take you to hear me out.

Ellis Short is to blame. He made the mistake of trusting other people to spend his money.

De Fanti and Congerton are to blame. They hired players unsuited to the Premier League.

Bruce, O’Neill, di Canio and Poyet are to blame. They failed to get the best out of the players.

The players are to blame. Too many of them are either not good enough or not consistent or, worst of all, don’t try or appear not to try.

Finally, the fans are to blame. “What?” I hear you scream. “How dare you?”

Well, the away fans are almost perfect. But at home, who amongst us can say that they never let out a groan when a pass goes astray?

When you get 40,000 fans groan it is loud and must destroy the already frail confidence of a struggling player.

Of course I realise some of this reflects the frustration felt after years of watching poor football with attendant poor results. But if we are to get the best out of our players, we need to somehow stifle our groans.

An example of how the crowd’s positive support can improve a player is to be seen in our Player of the Season, Seb Larsson.

In the past, I, along with thousands of others attending the SoL, would groan (and growl) when he made a reckless tackle. Now, that is gone from his game and he is playing to his true potential.

Incidentally, speaking of truth, watch his Arsenal post match interview on SAFSEE at where he says that it is the players’ fault that we were at risk of relegation.

If you are still with me (!) I would like to point out what, to me, are the on field problems that have led to our struggle this season.

Firstly, goals conceded. Take away the 16 against Southampton away and Villa and Palace at home and you are left with 34. Not so bad in 34 games, say comparable with Man Utd and their 37 in 37 games. The problem I think was that those hammerings not only crushed our confidence but led to us playing ultra defensively.

Secondly, goals scored. Let’s be honest: 30 in 37 games is woeful. While some excuse can be found in the tactics, the main reason in my opinion is inability or lack of effort on the part of our strikers.

To give an example of inability from the Emirates game, if Fletcher had gone for the cross from van Aanholt with his right foot rather than left he would have scored. On effort, I have witnessed Fletcher, Johnson and Wickham all either uninterested or appearing uninterested. This just isn’t acceptable in my eyes. By contrast, Graham and Defoe really give their all on the pitch.

So, where do we go from here?

Van Morrison sings – “It’s a pity they don’t feel the pain, that they should pay the price to play, to play the fame game, the name game”.

Well I am sure the players do feel the pain but I think it only right that some of them move on, for their own careers as well as for the benefit of the club.

In this respect, I would anticipate Brown retiring and Reveillere, Vergini, Roberge, Buckley, Bridcutt, Mavrias, Fletcher, Graham and Wickham moving on.

Now I know people will look at that number (10) and say you cannot have another huge upheaval in the playing squad. Again. I would counter that by asking what their contribution, except Reveillere and Graham, has been this season? Two haven’t played (Roberge and Mavrias) and the rest have been, in my opinion, little short of liabilities.

I haven’t found it easy writing this and imagine that those reading it will have found it hard too and probably controversial. However, I love the club and want to try to find a way forward that stops our annual fight with relegation. Perhaps by provoking debate we might find some answers to questions.

Who knows? We might even get Back on Top.

Peter Lynn: a musical theme for every moment

Peter Lynn: a musical theme for every moment

Tags: , ,

Salut! Sunderland is written, illustrated and edited by - and principally for - supporters of Sunderland AFC. The site aims to be sufficiently literate and entertaining to appeal to people who do not follow SAFC but enjoy good football writing.

One Response to “Reviews of the Season: blaming the owner, managers, players – and fans” Subscribe

  1. Jeremy May 26, 2015 at 1:41 pm #

    I agree with what you say about the inability of our strikers and the Fletcher chance at the Emirates is an excellent example. It’s not just a lack of technique which is the problem as such but very poor decision making.

    In that case, Fletcher should have tried to simply guide/deflect the ball into the net with his right foot. Of course he favours his left, but choosing to go for it with his left foot in that situation lead to him inevitably wasting the chance to score. I don’t understand what has happened to Fletcher because he appeared (at one time) to be the most clinical finisher we’ve had in donkey’s years (probably Phillips). Nowadays he would struggle to hit a cow’s behind with a banjo. Mystifying.

Leave a Reply

View from the West Stand: Willis and Maguire leave Portsmouth pointless

View From The West Stand (featured image)

Malcolm Dawson writes……..In a week in which a young bride excitedly looking forward to her honeymoon, wakes to find she […]

Sixer’s sevens: Portsmouth make it heavy at the Stadium of Light

Sixer's Sevens (featured image)

John McCormick writes: Let’s not quibble. We were not good. However, we had enough character to come back from a […]

Did beating Sunderland at Wembley compensate for not going up? Portsmouth views invited

Click the banner to find all the Who are You? interviews this season

NB: the official web address of Salut! Sunderland is now for those who like to bookmark the site. Using […]

Sunderland vs Portsmouth: familiar friends, or not quite? Guess the Score

Click Jake's image to enter

A technical fault means our headlines are not currently being picked up by NewsNow. This will seriously affect readership levels […]

Sixer’s Sevens: Burnley beckons after comfortable win at Accrington Stanley

Sixer's Sevens (featured image)

Malcolm Dawson writes….circumstances meant I couldn’t get to Accrington this evening, which is a shame because despite the rain and […]

Accrington Stanley vs Sunderland: victory would boost confidence for the Pompey test

Jake: 'Monsieur Salut must be in a bad mood again - no prize this time'

The invitation to supporters of our Carabao Cup opponents, Accrington Stanley, to answer a few questions from Salut! Sunderland has […]

Page generated in 1.359 seconds. Stats plugin by